The Sweet Tooth Fairy {Salt Lake City, UT}

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please read my disclosure policy.


While I was in Utah two weeks ago, Maria gave me a list of fun little bakeries that I had to check out. I went to quite a few, but my favorite place was The Sweet Tooth Fairy. I went to the store in Draper and thought it was the most darling shop ever! Lots of fun treats to choose from and the decor was super cute too! As you can see, I picked up quite the haul for just myself!! Luckily, I invited some college friends along for the ride so we could taste test together.

IMG_0155I loved all this packaging! The colors, stickers and logos make me happy. I’m weird like that though.

IMG_0168Ok, so lets dive in! This Chocolate/Brownie/Ultra Fudgy cookie was amazing! It was chewy and soft and so so yummy!

IMG_0164I got a fun St.Patty’s Day themed sugar cookie too which was flavored with Almond….my favorite!! I may or may not have hogged this one all to myself!

IMG_0197I got some cakebites too {which is a Sweet Tooth Fairy specialty!} My favorite was the lemon. The Salted Caramel was a close second though.

IMG_0160Now onto the cupcakes! I had a hard time not buying two of each kind because they were so gorgeous! This red velvet cupcakes was mighty tasty.

IMG_0172So was this carrot cake one.

IMG_0176I got this one because it was cute 🙂 Just vanilla.

IMG_0179Here’s their Salted Caramel Chocolate Cupcake. Yes it was good.

IMG_0182This Lemon Coconut Cupcake was probably my favorite of the day because I am obsessed with lemon. *See cakebite above*

IMG_0188This was also another one of my favorites! NUTELLA, ya’ll!!!

IMG_0191My husband would have bought ALL these peanut butter cup cupcakes for sure!! He’s a pb + chocolate LOVER!

IMG_0194And the Strawberry Shortcake cupcake was a showstopper! So gorgeous!

So, after trying them all, there wasn’t one I didn’t like! {Shocking, I know…} I loved everything I tasted and am planning another trip back to Utah so I can pick up more!!

If you’re wanting to visit The Sweet Tooth Fairy, here are their locations:

Provo/East Bay
1227 South University Ave.
[email protected]

Draper/Draper Peaks
101 East 12300 South
[email protected]

St.George/Pineview Plaza
2376 Red Cliffs Drive
[email protected]

SLC/Foothill Village
1334 Foothill Drive
[email protected]

Midvale/Family Center at Fort Union
1140 Fort Union Blvd.
[email protected]

Layton/Harris Plaza (just off Antelope Drive)
2065 North Harris Boulevard
[email protected]

Orem/University Village @ University Mall
1064 S 750 E
[email protected]

West Valley City/Valley Fair Mall
3599 S 2700 W
[email protected]

Murray/The Point @ 5300
5291 S South State
[email protected]

Scottsdale, AZ/Zocallo Plaza
15425 North Scottsdale Road
[email protected]

Share a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

9 Responses
  1. Lauren's Latest » La Bonne Vie at The Grand America Hotel {Salt Lake City, UT}

    […] visiting The Sweet Tooth Fairy, I decided to walk a few blocks from my hotel in Downtown Salt Lake City to this cute little bakery […]

  2. Nutmeg Nanny

    Almond is my favorite too, but all of these treats look so delectable I don’t think I would’ve been able to share 😉 I hope you had a great time!

  3. aimee

    Oh my gosh I’ve been there (multiple) times and they are SO good! They all look so delicious. The Vanilla and strawberry shortcake were definately winners. I ordered like 2 boxes last time and there almost weren’t enough. Lol I probably gained 10 lbs. (Maybe..) Oh well, that’s what sweat pants are for!

  4. Georgia @ The Comfort of Cooking

    …And suddenly I REALLY wish I lived in Utah! Everything looks so beautiful and delicious! Thanks for sharing, Lauren. 🙂

  5. Traci

    I am still and always will be a fan of the cake bites. The cupcakes and other desserts are okay, but it’s the cake bites I keep coming back for.

  6. Kellie

    NO FAIR!!!!! My mouth is watering so badly right now lol. You didn’t even save any for me. Shame o you lol. Every one of the sweets look so incredibly yummy!!!!!!!

  7. Stephanie @ Eat. Drink. Love.

    So I recently went to the one in Scottsdale and was actually pretty disappointed. Perhaps it was just this location, but we got about 6 different flavors and the cake on all of them was really dry :\ I always use red velvet as my test for every new cupcake place and it made me so sad that the cake was so dry and it didn’t have the classic cream cheese frosting. I have heard such great things about this place. Maybe I will try it again sometime and see if my first time was just a fluke.