21 Old-Fashioned Dessert Recipes to Make on Repeat This Holiday

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please read my disclosure policy.

Ready to add a little nostalgia to your holiday table? These old-fashioned desserts are simple, crowd-pleasing, and totally repeat-worthy. They bring warmth, flavor, and a little holiday magic to every bite, making them perfect for family gatherings or cozy nights spent indulging in classic sweets.

Peanut Butter Blossoms

 

Soft, chewy peanut butter cookies crowned with a chocolate kiss make for a nostalgic holiday treat. They disappear quickly at parties, earning their place as a festive favorite.
Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Blossoms Recipe

Christmas Peppermint Bark

Layered white and semi-sweet chocolate create a visually festive and crunchy holiday treat. It’s easy to make and perfect for sharing with friends and family.
Get the Recipe: Christmas Peppermint Bark

Apple Brownies

Fudgy chocolate meets tender pieces of fresh apple in a dessert that blends classic and fruity flavors. A twist on traditional brownies that delights every bite.
Get the Recipe: Apple Brownies

Frosted Sugar Cookies

Fluffy sugar cookies with a smooth frosting layer bring cheer to holiday gatherings. Sprinkles add a festive touch that’s fun for both kids and adults.
Get the Recipe: Frosted Sugar Cookies

Old Fashioned Apple Cake

Chunks of fresh apple are baked with warm spices to create a comforting, soft cake. It captures the cozy flavors of home and family holidays.
Get the Recipe: Old Fashioned Apple Cake

Decorated Christmas Sugar Cookie Bars

Cheerful sugar cookie bars that are simple to bake and delightful to decorate. Perfect for holiday fun with family and friends.
Get the Recipe: Decorated Christmas Sugar Cookie Bars

Apple Dumplings

Crescent dough envelops tender apples and bakes in a buttery caramel sauce for a dessert that feels special yet simple. Serve warm with ice cream for a cozy finish.
Get the Recipe: Apple Dumplings

Vanilla Bean Cut-Out Sugar Cookie

Soft and chewy vanilla bean cookies hold their shape perfectly for cut-out designs. They’re great for adding a personal touch with frosting or sprinkles.
Get the Recipe: Vanilla Bean Cut-Out Sugar Cookie Recipe

Buttery Apple Pie Recipe

Flaky, buttery crust envelops sweet, spiced apples in this classic pie. It’s a fall favorite that pairs beautifully with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Get the Recipe: Buttery Apple Pie Recipe

Apple Fritters

Crisp fried dough folded with sweet apple chunks creates a donut-shop favorite at home. A drizzle of glaze makes them irresistible fresh from the fryer.
Get the Recipe: Apple Fritters (Like The Donut Shops)

Hazelnut Shortbread Wreath Cookies

Wreath-shaped shortbread cookies with a nutty crunch make for a charming holiday gift. Enjoy them with coffee or tea for a cozy seasonal treat.
Get the Recipe: Hazelnut Shortbread Wreath Cookies

Classic Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies

Soft, nutty cookies topped with chocolate kisses bring a timeless holiday charm. They’re the kind of treat you’ll want to bake again and again.
Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies

Saltine Christmas Crack Bars

Crunchy saltines with caramel and chocolate create a sweet-salty holiday treat. Sprinkle with sea salt and watch them disappear from the snack tray.
Get the Recipe: Saltine Christmas Crack

Traditional Amaretti Cookies

Almond-flavored cookies with a crisp exterior and soft center bring elegance to holiday baking. Perfect for adding a little European flair to your cookie tray.
Get the Recipe: Amaretti Cookies Recipe

Triple Chocolate Peppermint Cookies

Chocolate layers meet peppermint crunch for a festive cookie that tastes as good as it looks. Ideal for gift-giving or sharing at holiday gatherings.
Get the Recipe: Triple Chocolate Candy Cane Cookies

No-Bake Scotcharoos

Crispy cereal, chocolate, and butterscotch come together in these chewy, no-bake bars. Quick to make and perfect for a festive dessert table.
Get the Recipe: Scotcharoos

Jam-Filled Christmas Shortbread

Buttery shortbread with a sweet jam center makes for a timeless holiday treat. Perfect for cookie exchanges and dessert trays.
Get the Recipe: Christmas Shortbread Cookies

Apple Cinnamon Bundt Cake

Warm cinnamon and tender apples make this bundt cake a seasonal favorite. It’s a dessert that fills the kitchen with cozy aromas.
Get the Recipe: Apple Cinnamon Bundt Cake

Soft Gingerbread Cookies

Soft and warmly spiced, these gingerbread cookies are a December must-have. Pair with cocoa or cider for a classic holiday treat.
Get the Recipe: Gingerbread Cookies

Holiday Buckeyes

Peanut butter and chocolate combine in these creamy, festive buckeyes. They’re simple to make and a must on any holiday dessert tray.
Get the Recipe: Buckeyes

Classic Fantasy Fudge

Creamy chocolate fudge that sets perfectly in the fridge without baking. A simple, sweet treat that’s perfect for making ahead of the holidays.
Get the Recipe: The Original Fantasy Fudge Recipe