This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please read my disclosure policy.
You know what’s funny? Me re-watching Victoria’s Secret fashion shows being huge at 30 weeks pregnant wearing tapered sweat pants and big ugly socks with frizzy hair and no make-up eating this entire pie.
My husband is one lucky man.
Anyways, I made a pie. And it’s the bomb. I’ve also been looking up new workouts to try after I have this little dude, but I’m thinking that my good intentions will be put on hold because of ….. this pie.
Blasted girl scouts and their irresistible cookies.
I think perhaps that chocolate and mint are one of my favorite combinations ever. Especially when cream is somehow involved. Umm, definitely when cream is involved. I do it because I can. And because I had 2 cups of cream I had to get rid of. And by get rid of I mean eat.
So yes, I made a Thin Mint Cream Pie. Thin mint crust, chocolate pudding filling and pepperminty whipped cream on top. HEAVEN! And super simple to whip out. I made the pudding from what I had on hand, but feel free to use a small box of chocolate jello to eat that much faster. And please make sure to add the whipped cream. My husband is a girl, doesn’t like ‘tasteless empty calories’ and scraped his cream off.
I was seriously this close to smacking him.
Moral of the story: don’t be like him.
More Mint Chocolate Recipes to Try!
- Mint Brownies
- Peppermint Fudge
- Chocolate Mint Cookies
- Perfect Chocolate Cupcakes with Peppermint Cream Cheese Frosting
Thin Mint Pie
for the crust-
- 24 thin mint cookies + more for garnish
- 1 tablespoon sugar
- 3 tablespoons melted butter
for the filling-
- 1/2 cup granulated sugar
- 3 tablespoons cornstarch sifted
- 4 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder sifted
- 2 cups milk
- 2 oz chopped bittersweet chocolate
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla
- 1/2 teaspoon peppermint extract
for the topping-
- 2 cups heavy cream
- 4 tablespoons powdered sugar
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 teaspoon peppermint extract
- Grind thin mint cookies into crumbs. Stir together with sugar and melted butter until crumbs are moistened and press into a pie plate. Refrigerate.
- In a small pot, stir sugar, cornstarch and cocoa powder together. Whisk in milk and place over medium heat until mixture comes to a boil and starts to thicken.
- Once hot and thick remove from heat and stir in chopped chocolate, vanilla and peppermint extract. Pour into pie plate and cover with plastic wrap. Be sure to place the plastic wrap directly on the filling. Refrigerate for 2 hours or until completely chilled and plastic wrap comes off clean.
- For the topping, whip cream, powdered sugar, vanilla and peppermint extract together until stiff peaks form. Spread half overtop entire pie and use the remaining to decorate the edges. Top with extra thin mint cookies and serve.
Equal toss up between thin mints or those peanut butter tagalongs…they need to put more in the package if they want me to share!
I LOVE Thin Mints!
The old reliable… thin mints!!!
tagalongs are my favorite
Thin Mints! So delicious! 🙂
Samosa are the best
I LOVE thin Mints! but, also LOVE the Peanut Butter ones:0)
Lauren, you are TOO FUNNY, I love reading your writings!! It give me great chuckles in the mornings:0)) God Bless you honey, may you and your family be blessed with your beautiful son..Tonya
Thin mints- straight out of the freezer! My fav!!!
Thin mints along side a glass of ice cold milk!!
Mmmmmm it’s a tie between thin mints and Samoas. So good!
Definitely Samoas! Though Thin Mints are a close second. This pie looks delicious!!
Thin mints for me. They used to have like an oreo one that I loved. No longer sell it.
I love the thin mints, but also the dos- i- dos (peanut butter sandwich cookies).
It’s a tie with me – thin mints & samoas
Samoas! Oh yeeees please! Thin mints are a close second, especially frozen.
I LOVE the Samoas!
Thin Mints, but Samoas give them a run for their money! Gorgeous pie!
My favorite Girl Scout cookies are cold thin mints!
Thin mints, fo sho. I could eat them by the tube.
Peanut butter patties
Tagalongs and Samoas – yum!
Samoas are my favorite!
Samoas, followed closely by Thin Mints!
Samoas are my favorite.
Thin Mints! I have to admit I have yet to try any other variety of Girl Scouts cookies but I can’t imagine anything tasting better than a Thin Mint, especially when they are chilled.
My favorite cookies are frozen thin mints! Yum 🙂
Thin mints, yum yum yummy!
I like then all but Samoas is my favorites. I want to make your thin mint pie. Sounds yummy!
My favorite is Tagalongs.
Ohh favorite cookie. Toss up between thin mints and the peanut butter chocolate ones. Oh and the lemon. And the shortbread. Oh who am I kidding I love them all!!!!
Have to go with the thin mints, but love them all!
Mine is a house divided- I love Samoas and my husband only has eyes for Thin MInts. What can I say. . . opposites attract.
My fave Girl Scout Cookie is the Samoas!!! Love them!! Thin mints come in a close 2nd though! I like to freeze them and eat them chilled!
To be honest, I moved to the States from Italy last year and so far I have only tried Samoa cookies. I love them! Now I really want to try the mint cookies! I need to make this pie very soon.
Thin mints have always been my favorites.
As a girl scout who sold thousands of cookies. (No, not kidding), this is a difficult question for me. I always advised others of the individual cookies strengths and weaknesses. Or when in doubt, which cookies had the most per box. (Usually trefoils and thin mints back in my day).
I think when in doubt, it would be Samoa, Thin Mint, Trefoil, Tagalong and then the Do si do just for it’s ability to be so delicious with a glass of milk…
It’s an even toss up between thin mints and lemonades!
I love Tagalongs/Peanut Butter Patties! I can eat a box in a sitting. Second favorite is Peanut Butter Sandwich/Do-Si-Dos. Oh! And Thanks-A-Lots that we don’t get in our council anymore! 🙁 Yeah, I’m basically in love with Girl Scout Cookies.
Thin Mints, but I’m starting to like Dulce de Leches.
Girl Scout cookies ALWAYS get in the way of working out! Ugh! My favorites are either Thin Mints or Samoas… I’ll go with Thin Mints, because I can eat a good 3 sleeves before having to take a break – samoas are quite a bit harder to eat that many of.
Thin mints and Somoas are my two favorites. 🙂
Thin Mints all the way!!!!
Samoas…AKA Caramel Oatmeal Delights when I sold them, back in the day.