Homemade Ice Cream Cake Recipe

4.85 from 13 votes

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please read my disclosure policy.

This Homemade Ice Cream Cake recipe is better than a store bought one from Dairy Queen, guaranteed!! Filled with vanilla and chocolate ice cream, plus crushed Oreos and hot fudge, this is sure to be a big crowd-pleaser!

I switched things up this year for Gordon’s birthday cake this past weekend and made this very delicious ice cream cake! Having a summer birthday has its perks and ice cream cake is just one of them which we all are not mad about. It was so so good and way easier to make at home than I thought.

ice cream cake slice

Ice Cream Cake Recipe

This no-bake, super simple recipe is made up of three different parts. All equally important and delicious.

The Ice Cream

I used two 1.5 quart containers of Breyer’s ice cream; one chocolate and one vanilla. That’s 3 whole quarts of ice cream OR 3/4ths of a gallon if you’re counting. See my variations below to switch things up.

The Filling

Falling in love with dairy queen crunch cakes at an early age, I’ve learned that magic shell and chocolate wafer crackers aren’t going to cut it for me! Plus, I could make it better 😉 So I used crushed OREO thins and store bought hot fudge sauce. And it was so freaking good. It was decided by all that that was the most delicious part of the cake.

The Frosting

I was going to use marshmallow fluff, but then upon further investigation, I realized it would have frozen pretty solid. I didn’t want to chance it. So, I just used whipped cream. My husband doesn’t like whipped cream (who are you?) so he ate around it. But it worked perfectly and tasted delicious. Easy to spread, easy to slice and added a little extra creamy bite.

finished ice cream cake recipe

How to make Ice Cream Cake

There are lots of different methods, sizes and shapes of ice cream cakes out there. I tried to make mine as simple and straight forward as possible, using 8 inch metal cake pans lined with plastic wrap (for easy removal) and store bought everything. When you’re planning a party, who has time to home make EVERYTHING?! Not this girl.

  1. Line two 8-inch cake pans with plastic wrap.
  2. Spoon softened ice cream into prepared pans, pressing out air bubbles as you go.
  3. Freeze two layers in the freezer for 8-12 hours.
  4. One hour before assembly, freeze cake plate.
  5. Unwrap and place one layer onto a cake plate.
  6. Add crushed cookies and hot fudge (that hasn’t been heated up!)
  7. Top with the second layer.
  8. Frost with whipped cream and sprinkles, if desired.
  9. Freeze until completely hardened.
  10. Cut using a large knife dipped in hot water.

Be sure to watch my video tutorial below to ensure success. And, if you happen to be working in a warmer kitchen, don’t be afraid to assemble the cake first, freeze again and then finish frosting and decorating.

sprinkles on cake

Different Flavor Combinations

Using different flavors of ice cream, kinds of cookies or fillings can really allow you freedom in creating a unique and super delicious ice cream cake. Here are a few ideas! The sky is really the limit here.
  • Mint Chocolate Chip: Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream + crushed thin mint cookies + hot fudge filling
  • Butter Pecan: Butter Pecan ice cream + chopped pecans and shortbread cookies + butterscotch filling
  • Chocolate Brownie: Chocolate Brownie ice cream + chopped brownie filling + chocolate sauce filling
  • Reese’s: Reese’s Peanut Butter Ice Cream + chopped Reese’s Peanut butter cups and chopped peanuts + hot fudge sauce filling
  • Ultimate Oreo: Oreo ice cream + chopped Oreos + hot fudge filling
homemade ice cream cake

So try this Homemade Ice Cream Cake Recipe out today! Whether it’s for a birthday, a BBQ, an anniversary or just because, this recipe is sure to bring a smile to your face. 🙂

Printable recipe card is below as well as a super helpful video! Enjoy!

4.85 from 13 votes

Homemade Ice Cream Cake

This Homemade Ice Cream Cake recipe is better than store bought, guaranteed!! Filled with Oreos and hot fudge, this is the ultimate dessert.
servings 12 servings
Prep Time 13 hrs
Total Time 13 hrs

Ingredients

  • 1.5 quart container vanilla ice cream
  • 1.5 quart container chocolate ice cream
  • 3/4 cup hot fudge sauce
  • 12 OREO thins crushed
  • 1 1/2 cups heavy whipping cream
  • 1/4 cup sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • rainbow sprinkles or other decorations as desired.

Instructions

  • Remove ice cream from the freezer and defrost about 15 minutes.
  • While ice cream is softening, line two 8-inch cake pans well with plastic wrap, leaving several inches of overhang.
  • Spoon soft ice cream into each prepared pan, pressing down to remove air bubbles as you go. Cover with plastic wrap and press down evenly to smooth the top. Freeze for 8-12 hours or until hardened.
  • 1 hour before assembling cake, place serving platter into freezer. (Make sure your platter can freeze!)
  • Place heavy cream, sugar and vanilla into a large bowl and whip until stiff peaks form. Refrigerate.
  • To assemble cake: remove ice cream layers and serving platter from freezer. Unwrap the tops of the ice cream layers and using the excess plastic wrap, remove layers from pans. Place chocolate layer on the bottom. Smooth an even layer of hot fudge over the chocolate layer, leaving a 1/2 inch border. Sprinkle crushed OREO thins over hot fudge and press down gently. Add vanilla layer overtop. Spread whipped cream overtop of the entire cake, add sprinkles as desired and freeze until ready to serve.

Video

Nutrition

Calories: 742kcal | Carbohydrates: 86g | Protein: 10g | Fat: 41g | Saturated Fat: 24g | Cholesterol: 133mg | Sodium: 316mg | Potassium: 632mg | Fiber: 3g | Sugar: 70g | Vitamin A: 1425IU | Vitamin C: 1.7mg | Calcium: 312mg | Iron: 2.5mg
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: frozen dessert, ice cream cake

Love ice cream? Try these other recipes:

Polaroid photo of granola bars

Never Miss a Recipe!

Join thousands of readers & get easy recipes via email for FREE!

Share a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating




56 Responses
    1. Shagufta Hills

      Hello
      I m looking a ice cream peach cake recipie. I made it more than ten years ago i loved it but cant find it.

  1. Andrea

    My birthday is coming up on the 27th and Dq ice cream cake is my favorite dessert. Might have to make this one instead of the store bought option ????

  2. Anne Marie

    This looks amazing! I have a little guy who would rather eat ice cream than cake…plan to try this for his next birthday treat.

  3. Arlene Basso

    I am making this today for my son’s 30th!! Do u recommend warming the hot fudge sauce to make it easier to spread or does it spread evenly right out of jar? I’m using Smuckers. Thanks!

  4. Catherine

    I make a version of this but use a box mix brownie with fudge frosting for the bottom. It’s been the requested birthday cake for a while now. But the oreos thins is genius.

  5. The Farmer's daughter

    5 stars
    I use 2 cups whipping cream whipped with 8 oz. softened cream cheese, assemble, frost and freeze the night before….

  6. 12+ Ice Cream, Nice Cream, Popsicle, Frozen Yogurt & Other Frozen Treat Recipes

    […] Homemade Ice Cream Crunch Cake from Lauren’s Latest […]

  7. Tamara H

    5 stars
    Our family loves this cake and we enjoy experimenting with different flavors. Thanks for a fantastic recipe! There is no going back to DQ cakes now!

  8. Alesia Schmit

    5 stars
    I made this cake for my husband’s birthday but with mint chip and grasshopper cookies. SO good. Next time I’m adding more fudge sauce 🙂 Thanks for sharing!!

  9. Darleen Green

    5 stars
    I thank you for the tips on making an ice cream cake. It was easy I used press and seal freezer wrap worked so good my cake pans were clean lol. I pressed the cookies into the ice cream then covered and froze the layers. No hot fudge. I stacked them easy. Used a cake board. No worries on freezing a cake plate.

  10. Devin

    3 stars
    WARNING to those who might be planning to bring this somewhere: Breyers, the brand she suggests tastes great, but it will not freeze solid enough to last for any amount of time out of the freezer. You should plan to serve immediately and not be able to salvage your leftovers unless you use a different brand. I made this for a friend at work, and brought it with me in a cooler filled with ice. It was already runny after my fifteen minute commute. Even after putting it back in the freezer compartment of my mini-fridge, it was a puddle by lunch time. This is a great recipe for a party at home, but maybe stick with store bought if you’re going somewhere.

    1. Nanny Sue

      5 stars
      I love Ice cream cake !!!! This is the Bestest Birthday Cake I ever made. My Granddaughter Lauren’s Birthday was on January 12th, she turned 14!!!! Wow time sure does fly by fast..She flipped over this cake. My birthday gift to my family is to make their favorite birthday dinner, dessert & memory-something you can”t buy .Everyone flipped over it! Thank you “Lauren” this was so easy & fun to make.

  11. Anna

    I have been wanting to make this recipe for months and will make it for my birthday next week! Would 9 inch pans work and the sides don’t go higher than 1 inch or so.

  12. Kim L Hudson

    How long do you need to take the cake out of the freezer before slicing? I will be making this and traveling for about a half hour before I can get it back into a freezer. Any suggestions on transporting this?

  13. Sara

    I made this cake for a party tomorrow. What is the best way to store it in the freezer until then? Currently it is in a pan covered in cling wrap.

      1. joanne morgan

        And you can make it in any shape that you make a cake. Oblong 9×13, square, whatever, just as long as it’s tall enough to hold the ice cream. Be sure to keep it in the freezer between each step.

  14. Molly P

    I put my ice cream layers in the deep freezer overnight but when I tried assembling them they started melting so fast. I had put a cookie sheet in the deep freezer for over an hour. What am I doing wrong? I popped it back in the freezer but there is already a layer of melted chocolate ice cream all over the cookie sheet.

    1. Francie

      Sounds dumb, but did you NOT take the 2nd layer out until it was ready to put on top of the bottom layer? Also when I frost a cake, i cut strips of wax paper, maybe few inches wide, and insert the strips about 1/2 way under the bottom layer of the cake. All the drippings go on the wax paper and when you are done, just CAREFULLY pull the wax paper strips out from under the bottom layer and your cake plate is clean!

  15. joanne morgan

    My friend worked at Baskin Robbins and made ice cream cakes. Cake layer on bottom, Soften the first kind of ice cream enough to spread and throw it back into the freezer. remove and add 2nd cake. Freezer. soften the next ice cream, spread and freeze again. That is the secret that she had. Keep it frozen while you work. Also keep the cake plate or whatever you plan to put the cake on, in the freezer. if it’s room temp it will start to melt the ice cream.

  16. BRENDA KINGPAPPAS

    used to own basking robbins you need to keep the ice cream a solid as you can when you thaw and mix in you lose the air which is part of why it is creamy keep everything including the cake as frozen as you can a freezer at a ice cream place is well below 0 not just enough to freeze a flash freezer is 25 or more below

  17. vkynj

    I’m going to make this for a birthday party this coming weekend – Aug. 3, 2019. I think I’ll freeze my pans for 15 minutes before I add ice cream to keep things extra cold – – and I am thinking about using either a 9″ or 10″ springform pan to assemble the entire thing, instead of 2 pans. and just layer it in the one pan.

  18. Louise

    5 stars
    I made this ice cream cake yesterday!!!
    so simple watch the video first… I used cookie dough ice cream then put on the cold hot fudge and then a layer of vanilla bean ..topped it with cool whip … Next time I would use Oreos and cream ice cream instead of the vanilla bean… or add crushed Oreos with the hot fudge …
    Thanks for a great recipe!!! Stored perfectly on the plate in the Tupperware cake keeper… just set it in the deep freezer 🙂

  19. Ice Cream Cake – Fran’s favorite ice creams

    […] Just remember to bake two layers of cake and to let them cool off before you can add the ice cream. Here is a recipe for fun at home […]

    1. Lauren

      You don’t have to necessarily freeze it for a certain amount of time after you add the cream, its just more to keep the ice cream frozen until you’re ready to serve. You can freeze this days in advance!

  20. Justine Bruzewski

    So far this cake looks great. I used cake for the bottom layer though. The only thing is about the ingredients, you should specify WHIPPED CREAM instead of heavy whipping cream (which is liquid) and what I tried using 🤦🏼‍♀️

    1. Lauren

      If you look at the recipe card, it states in step #5 to whip the cream with the sugar and vanilla before using. So the listed heavy whipping cream in the recipe card is correct.

      1. Justine Bruzewski

        I tried that and it didnt work? Maybe I did it wrong? I am by no means a very experienced baker. I ended up using whipped cream instead and it worked well.

  21. Susanne

    5 stars
    Made this for my son’s 10th birthday. It was delicious, and the whipped cream frosting was divine (and I usually don’t like whipped cream or frosting)! Thank you for this great recipe.

  22. Shannon

    5 stars
    I want to make this with a layer of chocolate chip cookie dough!!
    Does anyone know of a GOOD EASY recipe?
    I’ll be using Blue Bell ~ two step ice cream.
    I’m trying to decide if I should make a fudge brownie or a layer of thin Oreos.
    Any suggestions?!?!?
    Trying to stay with the ice cream flavors!!
    Thank you

  23. Kris B

    5 stars
    Soooo delicious and beats store-made! Instead of freezing a cake plate, I used a frozen marble board (we had one for mixing ingredients into ice cream like Coldstone.)